
Please provide final feedback to the creators of this submission below:
-
What did you like or love about this submission?
-
What did you find confusing or unclear?
-
What suggestions do you have to make it stronger?
Tamara
So creative! I loved it!
Joshua (1 like)
Beautiful! The art and storytelling made this story so enjoyable to watch!
Andres (1 like)
wowwww.... I love this projhect. great art.
Cheyenne (1 like)
Wow! You guys did a great job on this! The editing of your reel is amazing, and the additions of the fx really make it so much more immersive of a story. Great Job!
Pietro
Thank you, Cheyenne! We're glad you liked it!
Álvaro (1 like)
Wow!! You guys, I think I have found my Favourite short film!! :3 I honestly thought the song was composed for this story!! Incredible, It's been a pleasure watching your work. This is really really Good Work.
CONGRATULATIONS to All the Team!! Hope you guys Win or get a good recognition!! Never stop!! Greetings!!
Pietro (2 likes)
Álvaro, thank you so much for your kind words. I'm really glad you liked the story. It's really encouraging to get a comment like yours. Thanks again, and have a wonderful day!
Brenda (1 like)
Everything from the drawings to the use of lighting and the way the story progresses is all so good. The story is very compelling.
Pietro
Branda, thanks a lot for taking the time to comment. We really appreciate it and I'm glad you enjoyed the story.
Hally Bellah-Guther (1 like)
I skimmed through the comments below and can only second third and fourth what they said! This is incredibly creative but also extremely professional and I would be curious to know if one or all of you are already in the industry. Beyond that, the drawings, animatic, sound, flow, progression, all of it was quite magical. Though the subject of quitting smoking is dear to my heart because Ive been through it and been frustrated when people I care about couldn't, I get the feeling that this team could take just about any subject and turn it into transformative magic!
Belen
thank you so much Hally!! Yes, We are in the animation industry, altough outside US. Pietro is an animation writer, aranza works in production, javi is a writer too and I'm a visual development artist, however this was the first time that I did a proposal for a whole pice. It was quite challenging but I'm happy with how It turn out and I'm really glad that so many people like it. : D
Shayleen (2 likes)
You guys!! I love your reel so much. You have such compelling angles and scenes that use lighting so well. It's an inspiration for sure. I especially love the scene when the cigarette is watching the ad. The way you use the lighting and his small eye shift was really effective! Be proud of what you've created! It's so good. There's nothing confusing or unclear to me. You did a great job of developing the story as the weeks went along. :) Nice job!
Pietro
Thanks a lot, Shayleen!
Belen
thank you so much shyleen!!!
Joshua (1 like)
One of my two favorite stories, maybe my favorite :). Very inspiring story and great drawings and music.
Pietro
Thank you, Joshua! It's definitely hard to pick one favorite, there are many great stories on the dashboard :)
Belen
thank you joshua!!!
Varian (1 like)
Wuaaaahh!! You guys even made a song?! Amazing animatic!
I love everything about it. Mood set fantastically with story telling, use of sound and imagery.
Yet again I got emotional and I'm glad she was able to quit smoking.
I hope to see this short sometime realised into a full on animation.
You guys really inspired me and I love the techniques you used. Hope I can make things move like this some time.
what program did you use for your project?
Good luck in the future! 🧡🖤
Pietro (2 likes)
Hello Varia, thanks a lot for the encouraging message! Javier from our team found that song and we licensed it from a website. (Artlist) Both the tone and the lyrics fit perfectly. My sister was kind enough to record herself humming and singing the same song. Thanks again for taking the time to leave a comment :)
Varian
Your sister has a beautiful voice!!!
Pietro (1 like)
Thanks. I'll let her know about your comment! :)
Tracy (1 like)
I love the illustrations. I love the song! Beautiful story!
Pietro
Thank you, Tracy! I really appreciate it!
Francisco (1 like)
Amazing job! Every moment is very well developed and the way you tell the story majors every scene. The art really captures the emotion and the music helps so much to the narrative. Congrats! :)
Pietro
Thanks a lot Francisco :)
Eric (1 like)
Fantastic work. I have been fortunate enough to follow this story for the past few weeks and the progress you made has been absolutely outstanding and inspiring. Massive props to handling a topic like addiction in a very creative and inventive way. This is a story that may even be appropriate for children and could serve as a teaching them the dangers of smoking. Awesome job! All the best to ya!
Pietro
Thank you, Eric! Your message helped me realize that the theme of the sacrifice of the person you love also applies to oneself when trying to quit a bad habit. You have to sacrifice your own pleasure in order to obtain the greater good of being healthy. :)
James (1 like)
This was great, I loved watching this develop. I agree with the narration like others. But keep up the great work...
Pietro
Thank you, James. Great feedback on the narration, the final version of this story would definitely be with no narration and without dialogue.
Emma (1 like)
Congratulations! Your team did such a wonderful job with this story. Your boards are fantastic, the audio fits so well, and the editing is spot on. Although there are times when I feel like the narration is not needed, it certainly does not take away from your story. A well rounded story all around. I love it. Wonderful job!
Pietro (2 likes)
Thank you, Emma! I'm glad you liked it. Belen from our team did all the art, she's really great! Thanks for the note on the narration, we went back and forth with two versions but ultimately decided to include it for clarity. The final version of this story will definitely be without narration nor dialogue.
Matthew (1 like)
I love the moral of the story, it has a very genuine feel to it. I also really enjoyed the artwork, and the music! Very nice work!
Pietro
Thank you, getting the theme of real love across was one of our priorities. Thanks for taking a moment to leave a comment!
Taylor (2 likes)
Write for Animation Team,
From the first week, I've been excited to see how this story would turn out. And ya'll have created a beautiful, captivating story! The illustration style is great! the effects are well done. The sound effects well placed. I liked how the song Maria was writing was reflecting the emotions of the cigarette. Also, the colorful end credits was a lovely touch! Can't wait to see more of your work in the future!!!
Pietro (1 like)
Thank you, Taylor. This has been a wonderful experience for us as well, one that we're already thinking about repeating with other stories. Please feel free to reach out to stay in touch after the course.
Behnaz (1 like)
Incredible! I really enjoyed every second of your story! The visuals, the lighting, the storyline and the music were all make your storyreel great! Wonderful!
Pietro (1 like)
Thanks a lot for the encouraging comment! We're glad you like it!
Cassilda (1 like)
Never thought a cigarette with hair could make me cry. Awwwwwwwww. Everything is right in this submission! Did Maria finish her song?
Pietro (1 like)
Aww! Thank you, Cassilda. Yes, Maria finished her song and quit smoking.
Melissa (1 like)
I really like the concept of this story-- how a wish turned into a cigarette, and it ended up as the LAST cigarette. I'm unclear about the role of the cigarette-- how did it "help" Maria quit? But if fleshed out more, this has a HUGE potential to be a wonderful animation!
Pietro
Thank you, Melissa. I really appreciate your feedback. The idea to bring that point across is to further develop the moment of sacrifice, Maria's frustration, and her reaction to the cigarette "accidentally falling" into the tea from her POV. Also, we plan to include the moment in which she frames the last cigarette with a lot of care, showing that it's an important moment for her.
Sarah (1 like)
This was delightful! I loved the story and the art for it amplified it so much! The mood, the plot, the characters, the moral at the end. Congratulations, this was truly phenomenal!
Pietro
Thank you for taking the time to leave a comment, Sarah. We're glad you liked it!
Meredith (2 likes)
This turned out excellent <3
Pietro
Thank you, Meredith!
Richard (3 likes)
What a clever story. It was a fun twist on the idea of forbidden love and sacrifice. Very nicely done and great artwork. Congratulation on such a fun story reel.
Pietro (1 like)
Thank you, Richard!
Feedback will appear below after our team moderates them.
2) What you think about this submission:
Add New Comment


SMOKE ME
Once upon a time, a girl named Maria wished upon a dandelion that she could quit smoking, the wish was carried by the wind until it got sucked into a cigarette factory. The seed with the wish landed on a cigarette and gave life to it...
Written and Edited by Pietro Schito
Art by Belen Fernandez
Character design by Aranza Engle, Belen Fernandez
Music Editor: Javier Anleu
Thanks to: Carol Schito, Regina Rizo
Music, song, and sound effects are licensed for unlimited use.
Special Thanks:
Team:
Write for Animation Team
Aranza, Belen, Javier, Pietro
Share





